Alice Miranda Ollstein on Her New Book: Side Effects: How Abortion Bans Impact Everyone's Health
The ripple effects of SCOTUS' decision overturning Roe v. Wade extend in vast, concentric circles throughout the American health care system. Not only has it eroded access to abortion and other forms of reproductive health care—we are also seeing it have consequences for medical research, chronic illness management, hospital staffing, and more. This week, Alice Miranda Ollstein, Senior Health Care Reporter for Politico, talks with us about her new book, Side Effects: How Abortion Bans Impact Everyone's Health.
“Alice Miranda Ollstein's explosive reporting offers an urgent, on-the-ground look at a medical system under pressure, at the patients and providers caught up in the dragnet of the new abortion restrictions, and at the impacts on both reproductive care and completely unrelated services.”
TAKE ACTION
Transcript
Jennie: Welcome to rePROs Fight Back, a podcast on all things related to sexual and reproductive health, rights, and justice. [music intro]
Read More
Jennie: Welcome to rePROs Fight Back, a podcast on all things related to sexual and reproductive health, rights, and justice. Hi, rePROs. How's everybody doing? I'm your host, Jennie Wetter, and my pronouns are she/her. As you can hear in my voice, my allergies flared up, and while I'm feeling much better now, I still have the cough and all those things, but I actually feel okay. But I sound worse than I feel is basically what I'm trying to say. But it hit me last weekend, right before we left for our staff retreat, and so I was planning to make cookies and take them to the retreat for my carpool ride, and unfortunately, I did not feel up to it, so I did not make them. But my goal is to maybe make them this weekend because I have all of the ingredients, so that is my plan to make those cookies. They sounded really delightful. Otherwise, with the staff retreat, the weather was so gorgeous, and we were out in Virginia, like away from DC, and so it was just like these really lovely grounds that had ponds and rolling hills, and it was just delightful. The weather was nice, so we were able to, you know, spend time digesting and walking around outside after all of the hard work or digesting, you know, sessions. We were able to take buddy walks and talk about all the stuff we were talking about during our retreat. So, that was nice to spend some time outside and walk around. It was lovely. And then we had a bonfire one night or campfire, and there was stuff to roast s'mores. I'm not a huge s'mores person per se, but I did roast a lot of marshmallows and let them on fire and had some charred marshmallows, which is my favorite. So, it's nice. And then, this week has just been like hectic because we were at the staff retreat, end of the day, Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, and then this week was a bit of a scramble of trying to catch up and a bunch of things. Today's episode of the podcast is on a book, and I needed to scramble to finish the book. I was so- it's just been busy and a lot going on, but that's okay. I was very excited to just get out of the city for a little while and let's see.
Oh, the big news, y'all. There was big news. How did I forget? rePROs Fight Back won a Bronze in this year's Signal Podcast Awards for thought leadership. So, thank you to everybody who voted. Thank you all for your support. I am so proud of our team. And I guess I will just smush this with there is still time to vote for us to win Anthem Awards for belonging and inclusion, and then for human and civil rights. So please, if you have a minute, go and vote for us for those as well. But having these two awards happening back-to-back, it just really made me take a moment to think of how lucky I am. I've talked about how the podcast; my old boss really pushed me into doing it. And it wasn't really something that I saw myself doing, but it is my favorite part of my job now. I love all of the conversations I get to have on the podcast. I'm so lucky to talk to people who I maybe would not have talked to otherwise. Like I just feel so lucky for that. I am so grateful to each and every one of my guests who have taken time out of their day to share their wisdom with us. Have had so many amazing conversations over the years. I am so grateful to all of them. I am so grateful to you for checking out the podcast, whether that is through listening or reading the transcripts. I am lucky that we found a great editor that we have had this whole time. So, thank you, Meg and her team. And I am so, so, so lucky to have such an amazing, powerful team around me. Whether that is Tink Media, Devin and Holly, who help us with some of the promotion work for the podcast, helping get me on other podcasts and getting more people to find our podcast. So, I'm so grateful to them, but also just so grateful to Rachel and Elena. They do so much work behind the scenes, y'all, that you don't always get to see the work that they do. Elena’s, you see a little more directly, they do all of our socials, so all of the amazing graphics and such. That is Elena. They are so amazing, and I'm so grateful to them. They have just taken over doing the show notes, so I think this is one of their first ones, which is new and fun. And Rachel, who has been just my absolute ride or die from the beginning with this, she has been such a partner in crime in all of this, whether it is the very early days helping me work on outlines and trying to find difficult paths through conversations or doing the show notes, she manages the website, like she does so much work that you don't that you see but don't know who's responsible for. So, I'm just so grateful to everybody. But yeah, Rachel has been with me since day one of the podcast, and I'm just so grateful for that. So, thank you, Rachel. Thank you, Elena, for all of your hard work on the podcast, and then all of the support from the whole team at Population Institute. Thank you. Yeah, I'm just so honored and blessed. Our whole team is, so we are so grateful to the audience, to the Signal Awards team. Just thank you all. And yeah, if you all have a chance, please make sure to go vote for us to win those two Anthem Awards. We'll make sure to include links in the show notes again.
Okay, y'all. With all of that, I am so excited for this week's episode. I talked to Alice Miranda Ollstein about her brand-new book, Side Effects: How Abortion Bans Impact Everyone's Health. We talk about how it's not just pregnant people who are seeing the impacts, that the impacts of the loss of federal abortion rights have been far-reaching and have impacted so many other areas of health. So, I'm so excited to talk about this book with her. And y'all, it is such a great conversation, and it is such a great book. So definitely check it out. Okay, with that, let's go to my interview with Alice.
Hi, Alice. Thank you so much for being here today.
Alice: Thanks for having me.
Jennie: I'm so excited to talk about your new book, which, first, this is coming out on— Happy Book Publishing Day! Congratulations.
Alice: Thank you. It's been a journey.
Jennie: I really enjoyed it, y'all. So, you should definitely check it out. But Alice, before we get started, do you want to take a quick second and introduce yourself for anyone who's not familiar?
Alice: Sure. So, I'm Alice Miranda Ollstein. I am a senior healthcare reporter for Politico. I've been there for the last eight years covering the reproductive health beat in addition to other areas of healthcare. And yeah, so I've been tracking all of these trends since before Dobbs was overturned, in the immediate aftermath, and in the murky, weird moment we're in right now.
Jennie: So, your book, Side Effects, looks at the various health impacts that the overturning of Roe v. Wade had beyond just access to abortion. Do we do like a quick overview and then we can dig into the specific uh areas more as we go along?
Alice: Sure. So, I started with the most direct and immediate impacts, which is on pregnant people and the impact on miscarriage management, pregnancy complications, infant mortality, maternal mortality. And then I broadened out from there to look at other areas of sexual and reproductive health care. So, how access to contraception was impacted, access to IVF and fertility care was impacted. So basically, whether you're trying to get pregnant or trying not to get pregnant, you're being impacted by these laws. And then I broadened out from there to areas of healthcare that people may think of as completely unrelated. So, care for chronic conditions, cancer, lupus, arthritis, these other things. And then I really looked at the impact on our medical workforce, where doctors are choosing to live, how doctors are getting trained. And then I looked at sort of the future, how medical research on all kinds of things, directly on abortion, but on, you know, like I said, completely unrelated areas of healthcare that impact people of all genders, all ages, and the ways abortion restrictions are complicating that research, making some of it not even possible anymore, and the implications for the future on the ability to come up with new drugs and new cures for diseases. And then I end on the impact on the medical workforce and their political sort of awakening that we've seen after Dobbs, where you have both anti-abortion doctors and pro-abortion rights doctors getting involved in politics in new ways. They're out on the campaign trail right now, ahead of the midterm. Some of them are running for office, some of them are knocking on doors for ballot initiatives and candidates, and their medical societies are also getting involved in ways they never have before. Some of these medical societies, you know, either used to oppose abortion or used to try to stay completely away from the issue. And you're seeing that evolve and change. And so, I really want people to get a sense that no matter where you live, who you are, your age, your gender, your economic situation, your health status, this does impact you even if you don't immediately see it.
Jennie: Yeah, I think that really came clear, like in the book. Like that there was kind of nowhere you were safe. There were stories from California and New York, not just in states where people assume there would be impacts. So, I think it was really good at showing that it has such far-reaching tendrils getting everywhere. But the other thing I kept thinking about as I was reading the book is all of these other things that are happening or are going to happen that are just going to make this all so much worse. So, like reading one of the chapters, I was like, oh man, and now we're looking at Medicaid cuts getting added in on top of this, or the ways that Title X is being shifted, and like none of this is happening in a vacuum, right? Like there are all these other things that are also going to then exasperate this kind of crisis that Dobbs has already unleashed.
Alice: Yeah, and I think that, you know, I was very careful to emphasize that Dobbs alone didn't cause a lot of these trends, that it's just one of many factors and these things are all interconnected. But now that we are several years out from the decision, we just know so much more about the real-world impact. We have peer-reviewed medical studies coming out showing that this is having these spillover effects on other areas of healthcare. And I'm just glad to be doing this book now and not in the immediate aftermath of Dobbs because a lot of things people predicted have not come true. There have been some sort of surprising trends. And so, I was sort of able to capture that and explain why those things are happening and you know get a fuller sense of the fallout.
Jennie: Okay, let's start with the ring that most people are the most familiar with, right? Impacts on pregnant people.
Alice: So, I met with doctors and patients who had gone through really harrowing experiences that were shaped by the abortion restrictions in their state laws and how that impacted their pregnancies when things took a turn for the worse, which is fairly common, honestly. Miscarriage is extremely common; pregnancy complications are pretty common. And looking at these cases, in some circumstances, these folks were part of lawsuits, otherwise, they just were moved to tell their stories about what happened to them. And it really showed the clash between the legal language in the state ban and the medical realities and how those things often just don't mesh. And so, doctors kept telling me over and overlook, the way our state ban is worded, where yes, there are these quote-unquote “medical exceptions,” quote-unquote, “life of the mother exceptions,” but the way they're worded does not align with medical realities. And so, the wording can be something like, you know, you can do an abortion if somebody is at risk of a substantial impairment of a major bodily function. Well, who defines what substantial is? Who defines what a major bodily function is? And it's those gray areas that are causing really dangerous delays and denials of care in some circumstances. And so, I talked to women in Georgia, in Texas, in other states who, you know, when they had these, in some cases, really life-threatening or fertility-threatening complications, their doctors were scared of violating the state law. And so, they delayed and delayed, and they wanted to, you know, make sure. But those delays not only made the eventual abortion they were able to get riskier and more dangerous, it also just had an impact. And so, I think of one woman I talked to in Georgia who had her water break dangerously early, pre-viability. So, she was at risk of infection, and they just delayed for more than 20 hours to give her the abortion, and they waited until she was, you know, really crashing and qualified for a blood transfusion because that's something they could document where the doctors felt legally protected in going ahead with the abortion. And that caused her to have to get iron infusions for months afterwards. She could barely walk, and it was this really harrowing experience. And she felt like her fetus's life was placed above hers, even though at that point there was no chance it would survive.
Jennie: Yeah, it really feels a bit like medical chicken, right? Like, how, like, are you close enough to death or like major uh systems collapse before we can treat you, even though we know that's gonna be the ultimate outcome before you start to deteriorate? And somebody's inevitably gonna lose.
Alice: Right. And it's just really hard to know the inevitable outcome. The way these pregnancy complications go, somebody can seem fine and then suddenly take a turn for the worse. It's very hard to sort of predict the trajectory of their health. And so that's where these delays become really, really dangerous. And so, there's a medical term that I learned while doing this book called expectant management. And that's basically where somebody is undergoing a pregnancy complication and the doctors just sort of take a wait and see stance and they say, okay, let's hold off, let's not do an abortion, let's not intervene, let's just see what happens. And pre-Dobbs, patients were often given a choice of expectant management versus an immediate intervention. And there is medical data showing that when patients are given that choice, because in some circumstances it's not clear if the fetus will or won't survive, and the mother may say, okay, I'm willing to take this risk, you know, in order to wait and see if the fetus can survive. And some are not willing to take that risk. Some are like, I'm afraid for my own life and I, you know, want to go ahead and terminate. And so, the data shows that when patients are given that choice, it leads to much better outcomes in terms of maternal mortality, infant mortality. But expectant management became the norm in these states post-dobs, and that has led to a handful of deaths that we know of, there may be more out there, and a lot of near-death stories that um, you know, I think really illustrate the difficulty of writing a law to govern this area of medicine.
Jennie: Yeah. Immediately before I came on, I was actually doing an interview that y'all will hear in the next couple weeks about Black maternal health. And so one of the things people- we were talking about was Tara Walker, who then did die, and her family is now suing the state of Texas state legislators, kind of a slew of people because of that not giving her an abortion when she had needed one or had kept asking for one.
Alice: Yeah, and I think that case is an illustration of a trend I'm starting to see. It's still pretty small, but basically, doctors are in a very, you know, between a rock and a hard place situation right now. And they face legal threats if they provide an abortion and they face other legal threats if they don't provide an abortion. But right now, those are not two equal forces. The doctors really stress to me that they are more afraid of state enforcement for providing an abortion than some kind of federal or private enforcement for not providing the abortion. And so, these new spate of medical malpractice lawsuits are sort of trying to change that calculus to make doctors sort of also afraid of the consequences of not providing the care as they are of the consequences of providing the care. Because, like I said, these are not equal forces right now, even under the Biden administration. When the Biden administration was saying, look, doctors, if you or hospitals, you know, especially, if you turn away a woman who's going through a miscarriage or having a medical crisis in pregnancy, if you turn her away because of an abortion ban, we're gonna come after you for violating federal patient protections. And even in that circumstance, the doctors were still more afraid of state enforcement because it was just so much more immediate and it targeted them specifically, whereas the federal enforcement targeted the hospital, the employer. And so, I think cases like the Walker family in Texas, and there's another one in Georgia right now that's ongoing, are sort of trying to shift that. And we'll just have to see what happens.
Jennie: So, I think another area that the next like outward ripple that I think if you were not follow- not kind of as immersed in this work as you are, as I am, may seem a little surprising to people. And that was around, like, family planning and access to that. What were some of the implications you saw in that realm?
Alice: Yeah, so I think we're seeing a lot of interesting and sort of seemingly contradictory trends in the contraception space right now. So, on the one hand, we're seeing higher demand than ever for lots of forms of contraception, including long-acting contraception and in some cases permanent. So, you know, vasectomies are way up for men and you know, getting your tubes tied for women is also way up. And there are surveys showing that a lot of this is caused by anxiety around losing access to abortion. Just the stakes of an unintended or unwanted pregnancy are way higher than they were before. And so even people who are on the younger side, who were maybe on the fence about having children, decided, no, I'm so afraid of not having the choice in the future that I want to just end my fertility permanently now. And I even talked to a state lawmaker who made that decision. So, you have on the one hand increased demand for contraception. At the same time, we are seeing decreased access, and that's in a lot of different fronts. You mentioned the Title X program. The Trump administration is currently in the process of trying to overhaul that program to have less of a focus on providing contraception and more of a focus on fertility and helping people conceive. And so, you have that. You also, especially in the immediate aftermath of Dobbs, but some of this never went away, a lot of confusion and misinformation about what is an abortive patient and what is a contraceptive. And some of that was sort of just like informal online misinformation saying that IUDs can cause abortion or emergency contraception like Plan B can cause abortion, which is not true. It is medically not true. The FDA says it's not true. But still, some of that even made it into, you know, state guidance and enforcement and led to reduced access to those forms of contraception through, you know, state-run programs. Um, some of that has been resolved, some of it hasn't. But it continues to proliferate and be a deterrent and be a barrier for some people in accessing these forms.
Jennie: Yeah, it's one of those things that if anybody's been following the Supreme Court for a long time, like that conversation about some forms of birth control being labeled as “abortifacients,” like takes me way back to the Hobby Lobby days. Or more recently, with the dismantling of USAID and the arguments about birth control. That is currently there's $10 million worth of birth control in a warehouse in Belgium, and the administration saying that much of it was “abortifacient,” which very clearly was not.
Alice: Absolutely. So, I think this is definitely an area to keep an eye on. You're also seeing teenagers, especially losing access to contraception, and there is a sort of increased parental rights movement on the right to say that teens should not have the ability to access contraception without their parents' permission.
Jennie: Yeah.
Alice: Title X, when Congress created it, was supposed to be a means where teenagers could have that access, even if they didn't have supportive parents. Parents are sort of encouraged to be involved, but if somebody has, you know, an abusive parent or a parent who's, you know, incarcerated, or um, any number of barriers where that's not possible for a teenager, you know, I heard stories of, you know, kids who, you know, their parents threatened to kick them out of the house, or, you know, um, and so they really depended on Title X for that access, and they have lost it in Texas specifically because of an ongoing lawsuit. And we're just gonna have to see how it plays out. But it's challenging because in Texas specifically, you have a circumstance where a young person does not have the legal right to consent to contraception, but they have this obligation to consent to parent, if they become pregnant.
Jennie: Yeah, this is one of those that I definitely like keeping an eye on, right? Like this is how the attacks to overturn Roe v. Wade started, right? Was going after young people's access to abortion. So, seeing that play out again in birth control and honestly, even in gender-affirming care, like you're seeing these same tactics being used that led to the loss of federal rights.
Alice: I mean, you see it in a lot of spaces too, in the vaccine space. And so, yeah, I think it's very important to keep track of laws that are targeted just towards minors, because often that can be a preview of a broader trend impacting people of all ages.
Jennie: So, the next ring that you talked about in the book was doctors and impacts on doctors and doctors leaving the leaving states where there are bans. And maybe we'll collapse that in with then, like, the next generation, because it was also impacting med students and residencies.
Alice: Yeah, so I think this is one of the areas where things have not played out exactly as predicted. So, there were predictions right after Dobbs that there would be this mass exodus of doctors from states with bans, you know, a complete hollowing out of the workforce. And that has not happened. We have studies both at the state level and the federal level showing that, you know, the total number of, you know, OBGYNs and doctors in general have not changed that much. But what I really found in my research is that even a very small number of doctors in these states with bands who choose to either move out of state, retire early, change their specialty, leave medicine, and start another career, even though it's not that many total, the shortages in those states were so bad already that even that small number is having an impact and, you know, reducing people's access to care and services way beyond abortion, because obviously these doctors did not only do abortions. In some cases, they didn't do abortions at all. They just don't feel comfortable practicing in a state that is interfering in medicine, in their view, in this way. And so, I talked to doctors who chose to leave, I talked to doctors who chose to stay, and I really found that there was no right answer. Both were really struggling in different ways, both felt a lot of guilt in different ways.
Jennie: Yeah.
Alice: And it was just really heartbreaking to hear these stories and to understand why people made the choices they made and the repercussions that's now having for patients.
Jennie: Yeah, I think this was the chapter where I was really starting to think through then the Medicaid cuts that we're going to see because there was a number, a lot of talk about like rural hospitals in that space.
Alice: Yeah.
Jennie: And so, that was like the big red flag of thinking how these cuts are gonna then further be impacted. Our rural hospitals are gonna further be impacted by these Medicaid cuts that are coming.
Alice: That's right. And so, you're already seeing a lot of rural hospitals close, you're already seeing a lot of rural hospitals and urban hospitals close their labor and delivery units. And like we were saying, this isn't solely caused by dubs, but some of these hospitals have been very upfront and said that staffing challenges caused by state abortion bans are a factor in these trends. And so, like you said, with the reduced federal funding for Medicaid coming down the pike, that is putting more pressure on an already strained system.
Jennie: And I think it was just also worth mentioning then the impacts on doctors, I mean, the next generation, because that that you talked about how that was gonna have such a long tail.
Alice: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So, this is about doctors in states with bands losing access to really comprehensive training on abortion, but also pregnancy complications, miscarriage management, all of that. And so, it's mainly impacting people who are training to become OBGYNs. But I also talk to people who are training to become family physicians and other areas of medicine who are really worried about losing this access to this training. And so, they're really in a tough spot because in order to get accredited in their medical training, they need this training on abortion, but they can't get it in the state where they're going to medical school and residency. And so, all across the country, these thousands of physicians in training are having to seek out a short little crash course training session in another state where abortion is legal. And so, they have to really move heaven and earth logistically to be able to do that. And in the blue states where they can get this training, there's just not enough spots available. I mean, they have to train all of their physicians too. And so, there's this scramble right now in order to get this training. And I also really found that Texas is having an outsized impact in this space because it has some of the most residency slots for future doctors. And so, no matter where you live in the country, there's a decent chance that your doctor was trained in Texas and got their medical education and residency training there. And so, whether they are fully set up and prepared to handle these pregnancy complications is really of interest to everyone everywhere.
Jennie: Yeah, that that was a bit that like really surprised me. Like, I have an understanding of how big Texas is, but it was really surprising to see how many med schools and how many students were there that were gonna be impacted.
Alice: So, in order to really shine a light on that story, I, for months, followed a Texas medical student who was having to choose where she went for residency. And she was really torn. She wanted to stay in Texas, she's from there, she knows that there's a shortage of OBGYNs there, and she's so she felt this bond and this, you know, obligation to serve in her home state. But she was so afraid that if she did stay in Texas for residency, she wouldn't get the comprehensive training she needed to become the kind of fully prepared doctor she wanted to be. And so, she applied for residency, some in Texas, some in states that had abortion protections, and she sort of had a Jesus take the wheel, like I'll, you know, I'll just see what happens. And so, I got to be with her on match day where she found out where she was gonna be. And of course, this had not only professional implications for her, but also personal because she had an abortion herself at the very beginning of medical school. And it was right before Texas's ban took effect. She barely got under the wire, just days away. And so, she really felt this personally, and she wanted to bring that life experience in addition to all her academic experience to be able to serve patients, you know, with compassion and empathy. And so, this is something she really struggled with. And people will have to read the book to find out what happened to her.
Jennie: Yeah, that was a really compelling story to see her talking or thinking through like all of the reasons why or why not to stay in Texas. I mean, I found that with all of the doctors who were considering whether to stay or go, it was always focused on what was best for their patients. And yeah, I love the interspersing of the stories. It did such a great job of personalizing and helping you understand what is happening.
Alice: Thank you. Yeah, people were very, very open with me and really, yeah, just opened up about these very difficult decisions they made and the thought process that went into it. And some felt that they had an obligation to stay because if everybody left who would care for the patients of Texas and the patients of Idaho and the patients of these states with bans. But others made the opposite decision because they said, you know, if I stay, the quality of the care I provide will be compromised. And I need to be in a state where I can only focus on what is best for the patient and not my own legal liability.
Jennie: Okay. I this next chapter was, I'm trying to think, not surprising because I feel like I had kind of a vague understanding of how it was impacting research, but it was so illustrative because it is not an area where I spend a lot of time in my day-to-day work thinking about the impacts that it's had on research. So, how has this been impacting research, both for abortion-related things, but for things completely outside of it?
Alice: Absolutely. So, I think this will be some of the information that might be new to folks. And yeah, a lot of it was new to me. So, I kind of think of the impacts on research in three categories. So, one is research on the abortion drug mifepristone, and looking into all its potential other uses in medicine, of which there are many. There's really promising data coming out showing that mifepristone can be helpful for people of all genders experiencing other health impacts. I found instances where researchers around the country who are testing its potential to help with things like breast cancer or Gulf War illness, which is something impacting older veterans from Operation Desert Storm who were exposed to toxic chemicals. There's really promising data that this medication can really help patients in those circumstances, and yet access is under threat because it's mainly known as an abortion pill. And so, some of these clinical trials were canceled altogether in the wake of Dobbs. Others faced delays and burdens and hurdles and difficulty getting funding and having to jump through new hoops and take new precautions. And so, this is causing people who maybe could benefit from this medication to not have access to it. The second category is research on abortion itself. So, this is, you know, research into what are the factors that make someone choose an abortion versus choosing to parent versus adoption versus some other choice. This is research into where people are getting abortions, how are they getting abortions, what are the health repercussions of all of these choices? And this kind of research is more important than ever post-Dobbs. I mean, we have all of these questions that it would benefit society and the health system to have answers to so they can best care for people. And this research is becoming more challenging and risky than ever. And a lot of that stems from the aiding and abetting language in state bands where researchers are scared that if they even talk to a study participant about abortion as an option, and then that person goes on to get an abortion if they could somehow be criminally charged for that. That hasn't happened yet that we know of, but there's still this fear and chilling effect around that. And that's impacting not only how individual researchers are approaching this, but also how institutions are. And so, I heard so much about how universities are very cautious and scared post-Dobbs and are making it way harder to get approved for studies that focus on abortion in any way, even in states with abortion protections. Now, the third area of impact on research is just completely across the board in terms of the ability to study the impact of any drug on women of reproductive age. Women of reproductive age are already really, really underrepresented in clinical trials. You know, tons of studies of different medications and conditions only included men until very recently. And we've made a bit of progress. And the researchers and bioethicists I talked to are concerned now that we're gonna backslide on that progress because our entire sort of medical ethics system was set up under Roe v. Wade, basically, with the assumption that somebody would have access to a safe legal abortion if needed. So, think about it. If you're recruiting people to enroll in a clinical trial of a new medication, it's a new medication. You don't know what impacts it could have. If somebody accidentally gets pregnant during the course of the study and the drug has the potential to cause birth defects, which is quite common, many, many drugs have that potential impact. If someone doesn't have the option to have a safe legal abortion, how can they feel comfortable enrolling in the trial in the first place? And so, there's both the national and international guidelines for medical ethics for human subjects and research really stresses the importance of abortion access. And it's sort of- it's been the presumption for decades that this would be the case. And so now we're in uncharted territory in terms of this research ethics.
Jennie: This is one of those areas that's so fascinating. I recently read, I guess maybe not recently, it was maybe two years ago. What is it, the data gap? No, what is the and it was just fascinating like how women are left out of so many things, and to think that there would be that kind of backsliding is just shocking.
Alice: Yeah, it's really crazy how little we've made an effort to understand. Do drugs work on women at all? We just don't know. And now we could know even less because of the ripple effects of these abortion bans. And so, I think that you know, whether someone intends to get pregnant or not throughout their life, this could have an impact down the road.
Jennie: Okay, so I don't want to have you do like your whole book because people should read it. But I think it's worth pausing on the chapter about like other health things that abortion access is impacting people's ability to access other healthcare, people who had some chronic health issues, cancer treatments. I feel like that's one of those, and maybe I just haven't seen it as much. I think there was like a spade of early stories, and then I feel like it's kind of fallen out of the news cycle as much. Like, you're not hearing those stories pop up as much. So I felt like it was worth pausing to talk about that real quick.
Alice: Yeah, so I looked into how abortion restrictions are impacting people with chronic illnesses, both people who are already pregnant and people who just have the ability to get pregnant because of their age and gender. And so, in both circumstances, there were some really serious impacts. So, I talked to lots of patients around the country who depend on certain medications for their chronic illness, and those medications have the potential either to be an abortive patient or to cause birth defects. And the patients, you know, were taking them for all kinds of things: rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, Crohn's disease, cancer in some circumstances. And suddenly, after Dobbs, either their doctor or their pharmacist or their insurer said, I don't know if I should allow you to have this drug anymore because of these laws. And so, that had very serious impacts on their health. And even a short delay of a few days in terms of getting medication. When you're a person with a chronic illness who experiences maybe flare-ups of inflammation or another thing, even a few days of delay can be really serious and can cause, in some circumstances, permanent damage. And so, I was really shocked to learn that this was happening all around the country. It was happening in states with bands, it was happening in states with abortion protections, it was happening to people who can't physically get pregnant. One of the women had had a hysterectomy. A few of them were prepubescent children, some of them had proof that they were on contraception, and then a lot of them, you know, were too chronically ill to sustain a pregnancy. And so, they found this really burdensome and in some cases humiliating. People told me stories of having to answer questions at the pharmacy counter, sort of being grilled in public in front of other patients in line about why they were using the medication and whether, you know, it could cause an abortion. And so, some of this confusion was just in the immediate aftermath of Dobbs, but some of it has persisted. And in terms of people who are already pregnant, it just made doctors feel more afraid and constrained in terms of openly discussing all a patient's options. And so, you know, especially in the cancer space, and cancer occurs about once in every 1,000 pregnancies, and so it's not common, but it's, you know, still a lot. It's about more than 6,000 women in the US each year. And a lot of different treatments and even tests for cancer have the potential to cause birth defects or miscarriages. And so those doctors are now scared. What can I even tell a patient? And in some circumstances, patients with cancer are having to travel out of state to terminate a pregnancy in order to go back to their home state and begin cancer treatment. And sometimes those delays have had really serious consequences for people. And just impeding that doctor-patient communication in some circumstances can also be damaging.
Jennie: Well, y'all, you should definitely read the book. It was just so informative and great. And it I learned a lot. The stories were all really compelling. In this section, there was a story or two that really made me angry. Like, it is definitely worth checking out. Alice, I always end our episodes with like, what can the audience do? And as a reporter, I know you're a little bound around what you can say, but you do have one thing you can talk about. So, what can the audience do at this moment?
Alice: Well, I would really appreciate it if folks bought my book; tell your friends; leave a positive review somewhere online. I think that people deserve to have the fullest picture possible about what these laws around the country are doing on the ground. And the better we understand that the better we can evaluate what happens in the future. We have midterms coming up where the outcome could really determine where people can terminate a pregnancy, when and how. And so, becoming a fully informed voter, going into the booth to make those decisions, I think is something that would benefit everybody. And so, hope folks can help get the word out.
Jennie: And definitely, if you're not already following Alice on social [media] and all the places to make sure you can follow her reporting, definitely do that. I always make sure to check her out on so many issues that relate to things we talk about on the podcast. Alice, thank you so much for being here.
Alice: Thanks for having me.
Jennie: Okay, y'all. I had such a wonderful time talking to Alice, and seriously, her book is so good. Make sure we'll have to go buy it and check it out or ask that your library get it, read it at the library. But we will have links to the bookshop link for Side Effects: How Abortion Bans Impact Everyone's Health in our show notes. And with that, I will see everybody next week. If you have any questions, comments, or topics you would like us to cover, always feel free to shoot me an email. You can reach me at jennie@reprosfightback.org, or you can find us on social media. We're at rePROs Fight Back on Facebook and Twitter, or @reprosfb on Instagram. If you love our podcast and want to make sure more people find it, take the time to rate and review us on your favorite podcast platform, or if you want to make sure to support the podcast, you can also donate on our website at reprosfightback.com. Thanks all!
Find Alice Miranda Ollstein’s new book, Side Effects: How Abortion Bans Impact Everyone's Health, on bookshop.org. Tell your friends and leave a positive review!
Follow Alice Miranda Ollstein on X, Bluesky, and Instagram.
Vote, and become a fully informed voter going into the voting booth.